Coming up next –  Mary Poppen & Sandy Yu  Optimizing B2B SaaS Revenue: Mastering Upselling & Cross-Selling Strategies

  • Prioritise your Inbox daily based on Customer Health
  • Reduce Account Receivables through Payment Nudges
  • Increase Revenue with real-time support insights @ fingertips

Taking the Leap: Hiring Your First Customer Success Manager

Hey there! I'm Rishi, a passionate content marketer with 2 years of experience in crafting compelling content. I thrive on the power of words and the art of storytelling, using my expertise to create engaging narratives that captivate audiences.

Table of content
2.When should you Hire
3.Reporting structure
4.Key attributes & Skills
5.The First Year
6.KPI’s to measure Success
9.FAQ Section


Did you know that in 2020, over 90% of organizations confirmed having a dedicated customer success role, marking a significant surge from previous years? As we venture beyond 2023, the role of a Customer Success Manager (CSM) has never been more crucial. With evolving business landscapes and heightened customer expectations, CSMs are not just about ensuring customer satisfaction; they’re about guaranteeing customer success and driving revenue growth. But when is the right time to bring one on board? And what should their role encompass? Dive in as we unravel the intricacies of hiring your first CSM, backed by data, trends, and expert insights.

When Should You Hire?

Recognizing the right moment to onboard a Customer Success Manager (CSM) can be the difference between scaling efficiently and missing out on crucial growth opportunities. But how do you pinpoint that moment?

Signs Your Business Needs a CSM:

1. High Churn Rates: A rising number of customers not renewing their contracts is a clear indication.

2. Support Team at Capacity: If your customer support is swamped and unable to address queries promptly, it’s a sign.

3. Upselling Challenges: Difficulty in upselling or cross-selling to existing customers calls for a CSM’s expertise.

4. Revenue Targets Missed: If customer satisfaction is affecting your financial goals, it’s time to introspect.

5. Expansion and Diversification: Launching new products or entering new markets? A CSM can ensure smooth transitions and customer retention.

Growth Stage for Hiring a CSM

Expert insights from Gainsight suggest that the decision to hire a CSM should be considered when:

– Your customer base reaches 50-100.

– Your annual recurring revenue (ARR) touches the $1-2 million mark.

– The CEO finds it challenging to manage customer relationships individually.

As businesses strive to offer unparalleled customer experiences, the role of a CSM becomes even more vital. Their expertise not only ensures customer satisfaction but also drives revenue growth, making their inclusion in the team a strategic decision.

Reporting Structure: Who Should the CSM Report To?

Determining the right reporting structure for a Customer Success Manager (CSM) is pivotal for aligning company goals with customer success. So, where should a CSM ideally fit in?

The Ideal Department for a CSM:

Traditionally, CSMs have been placed under various departments, but a growing consensus suggests that they should report directly to the CEO or a Chief Customer Officer (CCO). This alignment ensures that customer success remains a top-tier priority. A study by Success COACHING highlights that when CSMs report to a Chief Revenue Officer, the emphasis often shifts to acquiring new customers rather than focusing on retention and customer outcomes.

Benefits of Different Reporting Structures:

CEO or CCO Reporting: Prioritizes customer success and empowers CSMs with decision-making authority.

Sales Reporting: Can be challenging as the emphasis might lean towards sales targets over customer success.

Marketing Reporting: Effective when the strategy revolves around customer education and engagement.

Operations Reporting: Ideal when the goal is to maximize product or service value for customers.

In essence, while the ideal department for a CSM can vary, ensuring they have the authority and alignment to prioritize customer success is paramount.

Key Attributes and Skills for a Successful CSM

A Customer Success Manager (CSM) is the bridge between a company and its customers, ensuring that the latter derive maximum value from the product or service. But what makes a CSM truly effective?

Soft Skills:

1. Empathy: A CSM should be adept at understanding customer pain points, showing genuine concern for their challenges.

2. Communication: Effective communication is paramount. It’s not just about speaking but actively listening to understand customer needs and goals.

3. Problem-Solving: CSMs are often the troubleshooters, thinking creatively to address complex customer issues.

Technical Skills:

1. Product Knowledge: A deep understanding of the product or service is crucial. This ensures that CSMs can guide customers effectively.

2. Data Analytics: Analyzing customer data helps in identifying trends and patterns, which can be pivotal in enhancing the customer experience.

Experience and Background:

While general relationship and communication skills form the core of a CSM’s role, their backgrounds can be diverse. They might hail from support, sales, consulting, or account management sectors. However, the most successful CSMs share specific traits like empathy, curiosity, a growth mindset, and an unwavering passion for customer success.

In 2023, as businesses become more customer-centric, the role of a CSM becomes even more pivotal. Their unique blend of soft skills, technical expertise, and varied experience positions them as invaluable assets in any organization.

As we’ve explored the significance and attributes of a successful CSM, it’s crucial to understand how to attract such talent. Crafting a precise job description is the first step in this journey. Let’s delve into an example:

Customer Success Manager (CSM)

Customer Success Manager (CSM) – Job Description

Role and Responsibilities:

Customer Relationship: Foster and nurture strong, enduring customer relationships, ensuring they extract maximum value from our offerings.

Product Mastery: Develop an in-depth understanding of our products to offer effective solutions tailored to customer needs.

Data-Driven Insights: Harness customer data to pinpoint trends, enhancing the overall user experience.

Onboarding Excellence: Guide new customers through our platform, ensuring a smooth and enriching initiation.

Value Promotion: Emphasize the unparalleled benefits of our products, identifying upselling opportunities that resonate with our brand ethos.

Educational Initiatives: Spearhead the creation of training modules and resources, empowering customers to harness our product’s full potential.

Feedback Integration: Channel customer feedback into actionable insights, continuously refining our offerings.

Qualifications and Requirements:

Experience: Demonstrable experience as a Customer Success Manager or in a role of similar capacity.

Educational Background: A degree in communications or marketing is advantageous.

Skill Set: Stellar communication abilities, product-specific technical acumen, and robust organizational prowess.

Innate Qualities: A blend of empathy, inquisitiveness, a growth-oriented mindset, and an unwavering commitment to customer success.

Benefits and Opportunities:

Professional Evolution: Be part of a dynamic company that places customer success at its forefront.

Skill Augmentation: Avail continuous learning avenues to bolster your professional arsenal.

Diverse Interactions: Engage with a varied clientele, broadening your professional horizons.

Incorporating such a detailed yet concise job description not only attracts the right candidates but also ensures they align seamlessly with the company’s ethos and objectives.

The First Year: A Strategic Plan for Your CSM

The initial year of a Customer Success Manager (CSM) is pivotal, laying the foundation for their long-term impact on customer relationships and business growth. But how can you ensure that this foundation is robust?

Onboarding and Training:

The first 30 days are instrumental. A CSM should be well-acquainted with the product or service, the company’s culture, processes, and overarching customer success objectives. Familiarity with tools and technology used for managing customer relationships is equally vital.

Setting Expectations and Goals:

Clear communication between the CSM and their manager is essential to establish role expectations and goals. Understanding key performance indicators, such as customer retention and satisfaction, and devising a strategy to meet these benchmarks is crucial.

Building Relationships with Key Customers:

A CSM’s effectiveness lies in forging strong bonds with pivotal customers, understanding their aspirations, challenges, and objectives. Regular interactions, feedback sessions, and proactive outreach ensure customers maximize the product or service’s value.

Regular Check-ins and Feedback Sessions

Scheduled check-ins and feedback discussions with customers are indispensable. These interactions facilitate feedback collection on the product or service, pinpoint areas for enhancement, and offer solutions to address any concerns.

In essence, a CSM’s first year is about building a solid foundation for customer success. From rigorous onboarding and training to fostering relationships with key clients, every step is geared towards ensuring customer satisfaction and business growth.

Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) to Measure Success

How do you gauge the success of your customer success initiatives? The answer lies in meticulously tracking the right Key Performance Indicators (KPIs). Let’s delve into some of the most pivotal KPIs:

1. Customer Retention Rate (CRR): This metric measures the percentage of customers retained over a specific period. A high CRR indicates customer satisfaction, leading to loyalty and repeat purchases.

A flourishing CRR suggests effective customer retention, while a dwindling one signals areas needing improvement.

2. Net Promoter Score (NPS): NPS gauges customer loyalty. Customers rate their likelihood of recommending a product/service, categorizing them as promoters, passives, or detractors. The NPS is the difference between the percentage of promoters and detractors.

3. Customer Health Score: This metric evaluates the overall health and satisfaction of a customer, considering factors like product usage, engagement, and feedback. It’s pivotal for identifying at-risk customers and enhancing their experience.

4. Upsell and Cross-sell Rates: These rates measure the success in increasing revenue from existing customers. A high rate indicates effective strategies in driving revenue growth through upselling (convincing customers to upgrade) and cross-selling (selling additional products/services).

In essence, these KPIs offer invaluable insights into customer retention efforts, satisfaction, and revenue growth. By meticulously tracking them, businesses can pinpoint performance areas, discern improvement avenues, and make informed decisions to bolster customer success.

Customer Success Manager

Conclusion: Championing the First Year of Customer Success

The journey of a Customer Success Manager (CSM) in their inaugural year is pivotal, setting the tone for enduring customer relationships and business growth. This article has illuminated the multifaceted role of a first-year CSM, from onboarding nuances to strategic KPIs. As businesses evolve in a customer-centric era, the initial steps taken by a CSM become the foundation for future success. Embracing the insights and strategies discussed will ensure that the first year is not just about learning but about leading, making a lasting impact on the organization and its customers.


FAQ segment:

When to Hire a CSM?

Consider hiring when facing high customer churn, low satisfaction, or when the company reaches a significant customer base.

Who Should the CSM Report To? 

Ideally, the CSM reports to the Chief Customer Officer, fostering collaboration and alignment with company goals.

Essential CSM Attributes:  

Soft skills like empathy and communication, technical knowledge, and a background in customer service or sales are vital.

Crafting a CSM Job Description:  

Highlight roles such as onboarding, relationship-building, and metric tracking. Seek qualifications like a bachelor’s degree and strong communication skills.

First Year Strategy for a CSM:  

 Emphasize product training, goal-setting, building customer relationships, and regular feedback sessions.

Key KPIs:  

Monitor metrics like time to first value, churn rate, NPS, and customer lifetime value (CLV) to gauge success.

6 Customer Success Myths Busted

Have you noticed how certain Customer Success Managers (CSMs) seem to navigate the complex world of SaaS with an almost supernatural ease? It’s as if